
I love Italian food.
I love it for its simplicity, its complex nature; the speed with which a dish can be prepared or the age it takes to eat a sumptuous feast. It is the often, contradictory nature that appeals so much – for there is a meal, a dish or a taste sensation for whichever mood you are in; whichever mood you want to be in.
Yet even though my shelves are littered with Italian cookbooks, or draws stuffed full or magazines claiming to offer authentic Italian recipes, I’ve started to question if what I eat is truly of an Italian origin; or simply a base note diluted by years of non-Italian “improvements.”
It all started with a piece of veal, progressed on to a Celebrity Chef’s restaurant; there was a twitter conversation about ragu before it ended with a simple statement whirling around inside my head – Spaghetti Bolognese is to Italian food what Chicken Tikka Masala is to Indian Cuisine.
Coincidentally, the veal was served up in a lovely, roadside restaurant in Bologna. It was one of those places that appeal to tourists, with their wipe clean pictorial menus and English speaking waiters. The hotel we stayed in recommended it, and even though we didn’t expect too much – Amy’s seafood platter far surpassed all expectations.
Now back to the veal.
My love of veal may not sit easy with some of you – but somewhere in a list of favourite meals will always be Vitello alla Milanese – or veal escalope. Whilst thumbing through the rigid plastic, drool resistant menu I saw the word vitello (veal) and the outline of a familiar image. It looked the same as that favoured dish, though this was billed as Bolognese style – still, when not in Milan and all that.
It turned up looking the same as always, but as I cut in to the cutlet I could see one major difference – there was cheese between the meat and the breadcrumbs. Cheese? Was this seriously an authentic, regional dish? Could they simply, by adding cheese to an already perfect recipe, claim it as their own?
On the same trip I indulged in that true local speciality, ragù alla Bolognese. It was served as a starter, with Tagliatelle and had a real meaty punch to it. There was little sauce, granular and light in texture but what sauce there was, coated the pasta perfectly to give a flavoursome bite, in every bite. It was as far detached from my first introduction to Spaghetti Bolognese as could be imagined; no heavy Plum Tomato, chunky onion and mushroom base – swirled around a fork before dripping all down my top – just like in one of those branded, sauce-in-a-jar TV adverts.
A minor confession here – I never cared much for the homemade Bolognese of my youth, and would often make my own with a jar of said, branded sauce. The sugary, heavy sauce would often boil down to leave not much more than stewed mince. Authentic, if you are a puppet promoting a Dutch take on Italian food. Though don’t worry, things have progressed a lot since then.
And so on to the celebrity chef – Jamie Oliver. The whole ‘is this really Italian?’ morphed courtesy of a visit to Jamie’s Italian in Leeds. I had a nice, if somewhat lacklustre antipasti plate – the meat was too cold – followed by Porchetta. Porchetta is basically rolled belly pork with herbs and salt. I’ve had it countless times, usually from street vendors who sell it as a sandwich with crusty bread.
Yet this Porchetta was served up with a sauce and chips. Hmm!
The dish came with the seal of approval from Gennaro Contaldo – Oliver’s mentor and spiritual guide in all things Italian. It had the herbs, but there were nuts, a meat stuffing and sultanas soaked in Vin Santo – an Italian desert wine. I’m not in a position to question the authenticity of such a recipe, it just felt as though this was a leap too far from street food to almost gastropub belly pork. Is this a take on Italian food, even from an Italian – just to appease British diners?
I put that question to two local Italians who are making an excellent name for themselves in Leeds – Alex Galantino (owner of the genuine article La Bottega Milanese Coffee Bar) and Mattia Boldetti (manager of Diva Italiana Bar & Trattoria – a restaurant that simply oozes Italian style and class).
I wanted to know whether the supposed rules I had picked up along the way – never spaghetti with a meat sauce. Always food, even breadsticks with wine and never milk with coffee after breakfast time were rules the average Italian stuck to?
It was clear from the passionate way they spoke, that although rules did exist – my earlier comment about the different forms of veal had confused a need to identify a dish to a region, with a proud tradition of utilising the best ingredients the region had to offer. Of course they would add cheese to veal in Emilia-Romagna (the region surrounding Bologna) because that’s where one of the worlds’ most widely known cheeses, Parmigiano-Reggiano comes from. The fact that veal was available throughout Italy meant that it would be used as a basic ingredient – yet would be adapted depending on the strength of the accompanying local produce.
My next view that stating produce was from a certain region – Amalfi lemons, Puglian Olives – was a means for supermarkets to add money on, by claiming them as one of their specialist items, was also corrected. Yes they do this, but only because they are the best. Even in Italy it is widely accepted that certain parts of the country produce the best types of food, and therefore they get an added element of respect; this in a country where local identity often means more than national pride.
All the way through the dialogue with my two guides, it was clear that there were three themes running through their answers – tradition, passion, ownership – all down to history, the products available and the need to be better, to live better, to eat better than their neighbours. Though a comment about Neapolitans claiming they were unable to read if you showed them a book on the history of Espresso coffee did make me both laugh, and accept that there would be times when tradition was simply “lifted” from another region.
What they both taught me was that if the tradition is right, it is worth embracing – it is worth fighting to preserve – be it in a personal or commercial capacity. Yes they may have to adapt things slightly to catch they eye of the Brit who has never been to Italy and thinks a dish is made in a certain way. Yet it is far better to trust in their knowledge and open yourself up to the endless taste sensations that existed – long before we Brits started to write cookbooks.
But sometimes a little creative license is not necessarily a bad thing.
I know that what I claim to cook as Italian uses ingredients you wouldn’t find in an original recipe. I eat pasta rarely as a starter, I occasionally have a latte late on a cold afternoon or that I glug bottles of wine without as much as a crumb passing over my lips in accompaniment. But is that wrong – should food not be enjoyed for what it is, rather than be hung up on rules and regulations (unless of course it is being sold as something it isn’t)? Spaghetti Bolognese is to Italian food what Chicken Tikka Masala is to Indian Cuisine – in as much as you won’t find either in their supposed place of origin. But then both are loved by a great many people – and who am I, a non-Italian, to say they are wrong if that is what they enjoy?
I try to adhere to tradition, but when there are so many variations on a theme (check recipes for Lasagne) – how many regions am I insulting by snubbing their traditions in favour of another? Surely it is sometimes better to make it up as we go along. Making sure to pay homage to a broader way of living – of which food is a massive part of that life.
It’s good to end by saying that last night I enjoyed a lovely bowl of Ragu with Tortiglioni pasta. I asked on twitter how those who read my tweets make their meat sauce. There was no one true consensus. Some used fresh or tinned tomatoes – even just a mere dash of puree. They used white wine, red wine or beer – even milk in one case. Whilst most tended to use what ever pasta was in the cupboard. The ragu I make is an adapted recipe from Giorgio Locatelli. It uses two kinds of meat, red wine, passata, garlic, soffritto (the holy trinity of carrot, onion and celery) and a few herbs – so not a true Bolognese sauce in ingredients, even if it claims to be in title.
As a recipe it is simple, tasty, takes an age to cook and can be served up at the start of a grand feast or, like last night, as a dish by itself.
Best of all, there wasn’t a plum tomato, mushroom or hand puppet in sight.
Just the way I like it.